When will Claude push back on a reviewer's suggestion?

Claude will push back if a suggestion breaks existing functionality, violates YAGNI principles (unused features), lacks codebase context, or is technically incorrect for the specific stack.

Why does this skill forbid saying 'Thanks' or 'You're right'?

To prioritize technical action over performative politeness, ensuring the AI focuses on the code's correctness and verification rather than social validation.

What is the order of implementation for multiple feedback items?

Feedback is implemented by clarifying first, then addressing blocking issues (security/breaks), followed by simple fixes, and finally complex logic changes, testing each individually.

How does this skill handle unclear feedback?

It instructs Claude to stop and ask for clarification on all items before implementing any part of the feedback to avoid partial understanding and incorrect implementation.

Rigorous Code Review Reception

Name: Rigorous Code Review Reception
Author: claudiodearaujo

byclaudiodearaujo

•

协作工具

Standardizes how Claude processes and implements code review feedback with technical rigor and objective verification.

This skill provides a structured framework for Claude to receive and act upon code review feedback, ensuring technical correctness over social politeness. It mandates a process of reading, understanding, verifying, and evaluating suggestions before implementation, preventing blind implementation and performative agreement. By prioritizing technical reasoning and YAGNI (You Ain't Gonna Need It) principles, it helps maintain codebase integrity and ensures that only necessary, verified changes are integrated into the repository.

主要功能

01Structured 'Response Pattern' to ensure requirements are fully understood

02Elimination of performative language and unnecessary gratitude (no 'You're right')

031 GitHub stars

04Strict technical verification of feedback before any code implementation

05Heuristics for handling unclear feedback and conflicting reviewer suggestions

06Mandatory YAGNI checks to prevent the addition of unused or 'proper' features

使用场景

01Evaluating and implementing suggestions from external automated or human reviewers

02Clarifying ambiguous multi-item feedback lists before starting any implementation

03Processing detailed feedback from a human lead developer on a complex Pull Request

What are Skills?·How to Install

Install with 🐟 Skill.Fish

npx skillfish add claudiodearaujo/sistema-de-narra-o-de-livro receiving-code-review

For use in Claude.ai and ChatGPT

Download Skill