Can it help identify statistical errors in a paper?

Yes, it evaluates statistical assumptions, power calculations, and the appropriateness of parametric vs. non-parametric tests relative to the data.

Does it assist with figure and data visualization checks?

It performs integrity and clarity checks on figures, looking for proper labeling, scale bars, and potential signs of image manipulation.

Is this skill limited to specific scientific fields?

While it includes medical and life science standards, its framework is adaptable to any discipline requiring rigorous evidence-based evaluation, including ML and social sciences.

What reporting standards does this skill support?

The skill supports major discipline-specific guidelines including CONSORT, STROBE, PRISMA, and ARRIVE to ensure research transparency and completeness.

Scientific Peer Review Toolkit

Name: Scientific Peer Review Toolkit
Author: ccam80

byccam80

0•

数据科学与机器学习

Evaluates scientific manuscripts and grant proposals for methodological rigor, statistical accuracy, and reporting standards.

The Scientific Peer Review skill provides a systematic framework for the rigorous evaluation of research papers and grant applications. It transforms Claude into an expert reviewer capable of assessing study design, statistical validity, reproducibility, and ethical compliance. By guiding users through a multi-stage workflow—from initial assessment to detailed section-by-section critiques—this skill ensures that manuscripts meet high-impact journal standards and follow global reporting guidelines like CONSORT, STROBE, and PRISMA. It is an essential tool for researchers performing internal quality control or formal journal peer reviews.

主要功能

01Research ethics screening for human subjects, animal welfare, and data integrity

020 GitHub stars

03Structured feedback generation for major and minor manuscript revisions

04In-depth statistical assessment of sample sizes, p-values, and error reporting

05Automated compliance checks for international reporting guidelines (CONSORT, PRISMA, etc.)

06Comprehensive multi-stage evaluation of methodology, design, and results

使用场景

01Conducting formal peer reviews for academic journals and conferences

02Evaluating the feasibility and rigor of research grant applications

03Pre-submission 'red-teaming' of manuscripts to identify technical weaknesses

What are Skills?·How to Install

Install with 🐟 Skill.Fish

npx skillfish add ccam80/thesis-writer peer-review

For use in Claude.ai and ChatGPT

Download Skill