Can this skill detect image manipulation?

It includes an integrity check stage where it looks for signs of image manipulation, such as duplications or splicing in Western blots and gels, based on provided descriptions or data.

What standards does the Peer Review skill check for?

The skill evaluates compliance with major reporting guidelines including CONSORT for clinical trials, STROBE for observational studies, and PRISMA for systematic reviews.

How does it help with statistical analysis?

It assesses if statistical assumptions are met, checks for multiple testing corrections, verifies power calculations, and ensures effect sizes are reported alongside p-values.

Is this skill suitable for all scientific disciplines?

Yes, it is designed as a multidisciplinary toolkit that adapts its depth and focus based on the specific manuscript type and scientific field provided.

Scientific Peer Reviewer

Name: Scientific Peer Reviewer
Author: jimmc414

byjimmc414

•

324

数据科学与机器学习

Evaluates scientific manuscripts and grant proposals using a systematic toolkit for methodology, statistics, and reporting standards.

关于

The Peer Review skill is a specialized toolkit designed for rigorous scientific evaluation. It guides Claude through a comprehensive seven-stage workflow—from initial assessment to detailed section-by-section review—ensuring that research meets high standards of methodological rigor, statistical accuracy, and reproducibility. It is particularly useful for journal editors, peer reviewers, and researchers looking to perform internal audits of their work against global reporting standards like CONSORT, STROBE, and PRISMA before submission.

主要功能

Reproducibility and transparency check against open science standards
Rigorous statistical and methodological design assessment
Comprehensive section-by-section manuscript evaluation (Abstract to Discussion)
Structured review report generation with prioritized major and minor comments
324 GitHub stars
Compliance verification for reporting guidelines (CONSORT, PRISMA, ARRIVE)

使用场景

Conducting formal peer review for scientific journals and conferences
Internal pre-submission review to identify flaws in methodology or reporting
Critiquing research grant applications for technical feasibility and design

关于

主要功能

Reproducibility and transparency check against open science standards
Rigorous statistical and methodological design assessment
Comprehensive section-by-section manuscript evaluation (Abstract to Discussion)
Structured review report generation with prioritized major and minor comments
324 GitHub stars
Compliance verification for reporting guidelines (CONSORT, PRISMA, ARRIVE)

使用场景

Conducting formal peer review for scientific journals and conferences
Internal pre-submission review to identify flaws in methodology or reporting
Critiquing research grant applications for technical feasibility and design