Does this skill work with GitHub's review system?

Yes, it includes specific instructions for replying within GitHub comment threads using the API rather than posting top-level comments.

What happens if a reviewer suggests an unnecessary feature?

The skill triggers a YAGNI check, prompting Claude to grep the codebase for actual usage and push back if the suggested feature doesn't serve an existing requirement.

How does this skill change Claude's tone during reviews?

It shifts the tone from performative gratitude (e.g., 'Great point!') to technical acknowledgment and action. It focuses on the code's correctness rather than social comfort.

When will Claude push back on a suggestion?

Claude will push back if a suggestion breaks existing functionality, lacks full context, violates YAGNI, or conflicts with established architectural decisions.

How does Claude handle unclear or multi-part feedback?

Claude is instructed to stop and ask for clarification on all items before implementing anything, ensuring that related changes are not misunderstood or partially applied.

Technical Code Review Reception

Name: Technical Code Review Reception
Author: dkmaker

bydkmaker

•

协作工具

Optimizes how Claude processes code review feedback by prioritizing technical verification and architectural integrity over social agreement.

This skill establishes a high-rigor protocol for Claude when receiving feedback on code changes. It replaces performative politeness and blind implementation with a structured response pattern that emphasizes understanding requirements, verifying suggestions against the actual codebase, and providing reasoned technical pushback. By enforcing YAGNI checks and preventing partial implementations of unclear feedback, it ensures that your codebase remains lean and functional while maintaining a professional, action-oriented communication style during the review process.

主要功能

01Enforces a verify-before-implement response pattern for all feedback.

02Includes automatic YAGNI (You Ain't Gonna Need It) validation for suggested features.

031 GitHub stars

04Eliminates performative agreement phrases like 'You're absolutely right!'

05Provides a structured workflow for handling multi-item feedback and regressions.

06Differentiates between trusted partner feedback and skeptical external reviews.

使用场景

01Responding to complex GitHub Pull Request comments with technical precision.

02Evaluating external contributor suggestions for architectural compatibility.

03Clarifying ambiguous change requests before modifying critical system logic.

What are Skills?·How to Install

Install with 🐟 Skill.Fish

npx skillfish add dkmaker/my-claude-plugins receiving-code-review

For use in Claude.ai and ChatGPT

Download Skill