Does this skill allow Claude to push back against suggestions?

Yes. It provides a framework for pushing back using technical reasoning, such as identifying broken functionality, lack of context, or violations of YAGNI principles.

Why does this skill discourage saying 'thank you' or 'you're right'?

The skill prioritizes technical action and correctness over social performance. By removing 'fluff,' Claude focuses on verifying the feedback against the codebase reality rather than providing blind agreement.

How does the skill handle feedback from external reviewers?

It treats external feedback as suggestions to be skeptically evaluated. It checks if the suggestion is technically correct for the specific stack, checks for regressions, and verifies context before proceeding.

What happens if a reviewer's feedback is unclear?

The skill mandates an immediate stop. It prevents partial implementation and requires Claude to ask for clarification on all items to ensure the complete technical context is understood.

Technical Code Review Reception

Name: Technical Code Review Reception
Author: anortham

byanortham

0•

协作工具

Standardizes the reception of code review feedback by prioritizing technical verification and rigor over performative agreement.

This skill provides a rigorous framework for Claude to process code review feedback with technical objectivity. It enforces a 'verify before acting' protocol that prevents blind implementation of suggestions, eliminates performative social responses like 'Great point!', and ensures all feedback is technically sound for the specific codebase context. By providing structured patterns for handling unclear instructions and pushing back against incorrect suggestions, it helps maintain architectural integrity and prevents unnecessary feature bloat through built-in YAGNI checks.

主要功能

01Enforces technical verification before implementing any review suggestion

02Implements a 'skeptical evaluation' process for external reviewer feedback

03Eliminates performative and fluff-filled social responses to stay focused on code

04Provides structured protocols for clarifying ambiguous or partial feedback

05Includes YAGNI (You Aren't Gonna Need It) validation for suggested features

060 GitHub stars

使用场景

01Processing complex PR feedback from multiple reviewers without introducing regressions

02Defending architectural decisions against technically questionable suggestions

03Clarifying vague human partner instructions before starting implementation

What are Skills?·How to Install

Install with 🐟 Skill.Fish

npx skillfish add anortham/razorback receiving-code-review

For use in Claude.ai and ChatGPT

主要功能

01Enforces technical verification before implementing any review suggestion

02Implements a 'skeptical evaluation' process for external reviewer feedback

03Eliminates performative and fluff-filled social responses to stay focused on code

04Provides structured protocols for clarifying ambiguous or partial feedback

05Includes YAGNI (You Aren't Gonna Need It) validation for suggested features

060 GitHub stars

使用场景

01Processing complex PR feedback from multiple reviewers without introducing regressions

02Defending architectural decisions against technically questionable suggestions

03Clarifying vague human partner instructions before starting implementation

What are Skills?·How to Install

Install with 🐟 Skill.Fish

npx skillfish add anortham/razorback receiving-code-review

For use in Claude.ai and ChatGPT